This blog is my portfolio of learning. It contains quality work that I am proud of.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Why the England Referee was unfair


By Elise
Team 14, Fendalton School
October 2007

When the All Blacks lost to France in the Rugby World Cup quarterfinal the New Zealand supporters were watching in shock as the French celebrated. The players, supporters and coaches were all gutted and disappointed with our loss. No other country would have been as disappointed as we were. This is the earliest the All Blacks have ever been out of the Rugby World Cup.

I think the England referee was unfair because he was on the side of the French team so that the English team would get to play an easier team in the semi-final.
In the first half Luke Macalister got sent off for 10 minutes for what looked like a high tackle but wasn't. The referee was definitely on the French side because a fair referee wouldn't pull up one side for nothing.

During the second half the referee didn't see a forward pass from the French that scored a try, which was also converted. If the referee had seen this forward pass, then the All Blacks would have won and had a chance of getting through to the finals.

Everybody is blaming the loss all on the All blacks and the coaches but it was partly the All blacks bad team work but most of it was unfair refereeing. The final score was 18-20 to France. The All Blacks now have to wait another 4 years to have another try at getting the title of the Rugby World Cup. All we can do now is hope that the refereeing is fair unlike this year’s quarterfinal.


4 comments:

sporte said...

Thankyou very much for sharing your blog with us-Ann and Sue from St Clair school in Dunedin.

Banna said...

Feedback from Anna
Surface features- Exceptional because it captures my attention and there is no spelling mistakes.
Deeper features- Great because your ideas are realeted to the topic
Title- Great because the title states your argument and makes me want to read the story
Organisation of the writing- Great because your arguments are in order with the strongest at the end and the weakest in the middle.
Strenth of arguments- Execptinal because I am staying on the topic
Publication- Great because there is a bold title and the text is easy to read.

Next steps- To add some photos related to the topic.

Anonymous said...

Feedback from Christie
The conclusions good because it summarises your story. I think that the arguments are strong and the story is well set out with the strongest argument at the end and the weakest in the middle.

Anonymous said...

Feedback from lucy
I think that this is a very good piece of writing because it states the points in a clear way. The photos are interesting because they helped me to understand the writing better.